General
Comments 13

How many is too many?

As much as I love languages, I’ve always limited myself to learning ONE or TWO at a time.  I’m not sure I admire people who say they are learning six languages at the same time.  Mostly, I’m just skeptical of them.

Personally, I think it’s okay to learn multiple languages at the same time if you’re definitely at different levels in each language.  For me, my Korean isn’t impeccable or anything but my Korean abilities >>>>>>> my Japanese abilities.  Now, when I learn new things in Japanese, I liken them to things I already knew in Korean and that actually helps me learn better.  It also helps that Japanese and Korean have quite a bit of similarities, both in terms of vocabulary, SOME general grammar constructions (though I find that most Japanese grammar is quite different from Korean grammar), and even some expressions.  So studying Japanese sometimes helps me reinforce what I already know in Korean; at least, it forces me to think, “Hm. Is there an equivalent expression in Korean?” or “How would I express this in Korean?”  I think it might actually be helpful to learn two somewhat related or linguistically similar languages at the same time rather than learning just one or two completely unrelated languages.  That way, if you get exhausted or frustrated studying one language, you can switch to the other one but still somewhat unconsciously be reviewing the other one.  Does that even make sense?  Haha.  At least, that’s the kind of relationship I have with Japanese and Korean.  Also, once you’re quite comfortable with one language, you could use that language to learn another linguistically similar one.  For example, learning Japanese using Korean (or vice versa) is probably an infinity times easier than learning either one from English, just because English is SO different from Japanese and Korean.  (But, of course, you’d probably want to stick to using English to learn languages French or Spanish, rather than any East Asian language.)

But suppose you’re learning like two NEW (zero-experience) languages at the same time.  If they’re completely unrelated to each other, personally, I feel that you’d be doing a disservice to yourself.  You’d hinder your progress in BOTH languages.  It may take you longer to digest different sets of vocabulary and completely different grammar points.  And I feel that the time that you divide between two languages (specifically if you’re at the zero-experience, BEGINNER level in both) could be better spent in progressing faster in ONE language.  Once you reach a certain degree of comfort in one language, I think it’ll be worth starting a new one.  That way, like I said, if you ever get tired of one, you could take a break and study the other, even if the languages are unrelated.  On the other hand, if you’re starting from ground zero in two “similar” languages – like Hindi and Marathi or Korean and Japanese, again, I think you’d be at a disadvantage.  It’s possible you could easily get mixed up and hinder your progress in both.

Honestly, I’m VERY skeptical of people who say they’re learning Korean, Japanese, Vietnamese, Thai, French, Spanish, etc. etc. all at the same time.  I just don’t think it’s a fruitful way to become proficient in ANY language.  But that’s just my opinion.  What do you guys think?  (*SOB* Not that anyone leaves me any comments anymore…)

This entry was posted in: General

by

Writer by day, writer by night. Learning Korean and (some) Japanese since 2010.

13 Comments

  1. Me too! Learning a language involves so much effort and time, it’s impossible to say you are learning a few unrelated languages at one go. I’ve heard many people saying such stuff though. O.o I wonder how they define ‘learning a language’.

    p.s. I’m a regular silent reader! hahahaha :D

    Like

      • I can be silent and vocal at the same time. ㅋㅋㅋ

        Btw, I’m a silent reader of both your blogs. I think I don’t sound silent now, do I?

        Like

  2. I don’t know anything about learning three or more languages at a time. Once, I was studying both Japanese and Korean – that was a headache. Now, I just stick to one (I dropped Japanese for the moment b/c I’m more interested in Korea and Korean was harder for me) Nonetheless, if people have tons of free time and love language study, studying multiple languages at once should be feasible. I’ve yet to see someone pull it off though.

    Like

      • Yeah but he’s a genius ahahaha. But seriously speaking, I don’t know if he staggered his language-learning to learning two or three at a time or if he actually did study his 157698298 languages all at the same time. XD

        Like

  3. I totally agree with you. One language at a time!
    And yes, I also believe that you should focus on reaching a good level at your L2 before, and then learn the L3 through L2 material, so you don’t forget the latter. (Sadly it happens, my mother lost her proficiency in Spanish when she learned French…) Although as you said, if the L3 is related to your L1 and not your L2, it’s a waste of time. But in your case (L2 Korean and L3 Japanese) I feel like it’s the best thing to do. ^^

    Like

  4. I agree with you. My knowledge of Japanese is helping me with Korean but that’s because I started Japanese nearly 4 years before Korean. And althougj I want to start learning Chinese I won’t until I reach an inyermediate level at Korean.
    But anyway, I think that only counts for self-studying. I’ve been studying English and French at school for some time and I started Latin and ancient Greek at school too at the same time as Korean but I didn’t get confused or anything… Maybe it’s because I haven’t worked on these languages outside class, I don’t know.

    Like

  5. Pingback: 5 Tips on taking on another foreign language | 반짝반짝

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s